Can
Hormone Replacement Therapy Cause Acne?
Dear Dr. Wilkinson:
I’m 45 and for a number of reasons I’m considering
taking hormone replacement therapy. However, I’ve heard
hormones can cause acne. That sounds like a double whammy I’d
rather avoid: the acne I suffered through during puberty, and
the hot flashes of menopause! Your thoughts? -
Amy
Dear
Amy:
While
I won’t interfere with the dialogue you’re having
with your regular physician regarding whether or not to take hormones,
I will comment on your question about the link between hormones
and acne.
By
far, the preponderance of the research indicates that it’s
the so-called “male” hormones (androgens), which actually
occur naturally in both sexes, that play the biggest role in causing
acne, both in adolescent girls and boys, and in women taking supplemental
testosterone as part of a hormone treatment regimen.
And,
studies have suggested that it isn’t necessarily that acne
sufferers have high levels of androgens in their blood, but rather
that they have had a significant increase in levels of those hormones
compared to their own baseline. It’s well known, for example,
that natural levels of testosterone in a woman’s body start
to decline gradually after about age 25, and continue to decline
throughout the rest of her life. Therefore, it makes sense that
if a woman in her mid-40s starts taking a hormone replacement
regimen that includes testosterone, she may experience some of
the consequences known to be linked to increases in testosterone
— such as acne.
On
the other hand, oral contraceptives (which contain only “female”
hormones related to estrogen and progesterone, without added testosterone)
have been shown to significantly improve the skin of women who
have naturally occurring adult acne. As you can see, it isn’t
the sex hormones in general that trigger this skin scourge; it’s
a surge of androgens — “male” hormones.
At
this point I should clarify that it isn’t testosterone per
se that is the culprit. In the skin, testosterone actually has
little effect in this regard. Enzymes that are present in the
skin, however, and particularly an enzyme called 5 alpha-reductase,
convert testosterone into activated forms such as DHEA-S (dehydroepiandrosterone
sulfate), which then can link up with receptors in the oil-producing
glands within the follicles. It is those activated androgens,
connected to the appropriate receptors in the follicles, that
can trigger acne.
So,
Amy, if you and your physician are not planning to include testosterone
in your hormone replacement regimen, it’s highly unlikely
that acne will be something you will have to contend with. If
testosterone is to be included, however, then whether or not you
develop acne lesions will depend on the levels of 5 alpha-reductase
you have naturally in your follicles, and on whether you have
an abundance of receptors for activated androgens.
If
testosterone is considered to be an essential part of your hormone
therapy, and taking supplemental testosterone does result in your
developing acne, all is not lost. Well formulated acne treatments
include agents that can block the action of 5 alpha-reductase.
Some of those agents include azelaic acid, green tea extract,
NDGA, oleanolic acid, and zinc.
-
Dr. Wilkinson